A statue of Lady Justice famously sits atop the Old Bailey in London, holding a sword in one hand and scales in the other.
Unlike traditional depictions of Lady Justice, she has no blindfold, suggesting that she does not need one to embody impartiality. Rooted in classical myth, her omnipresent gaze is so powerful that it also spans across Europe, from the Palace of Justice in Rome to the Fountain of Justice in Frankfurt.
In Italian, German and other languages that use grammatical gender, the word ‘justice’ is classed as feminine (i.e., la justicia in Spanish; la justice in French). In many ancient cultures, justice is commonly depicted as a goddess rather than a god (i.e., Ma’at in ancient Egypt; Justicia in Ancient Rome; Themis in ancient Greece). This got me thinking about gender and justice today: If justice is a woman, why are women so often ill-served by the criminal justice system?
Unhelpful binaries in justice and gender
Like any concept, ‘justice’ is incredibly difficult to define. Similarly, the concept of gender is very complex. Yet, both gender and justice are all-too-often treated as binaries, where justice either means punishment or rehabilitation, and gender means either male or female (with all the expected behaviours and characteristics that may imply).
The reality is more complex: Definitions vary across time, place and context. With this in mind, inequalities can emerge in the way that justice is delivered, or perhaps even denied. Because there is no fixed definition of justice, we are constantly redefining how we seek it and to whom we serve it. When we treat justice as either/or, it gets mapped onto binary conceptions of gender in unhelpful ways.
Mapping justice onto gender
Principles such as fairness, equality, and accessibility uphold the justice system in the UK. You might notice that these buzzwords are complex concepts in themselves. How do we make sure we are achieving them? Is it only the responsibility of the justice system to do so? A system built by men, for men, can only go so far in upholding these aims. As the saying goes, “justice is not blind”. Characteristics such as gender, age and ethnicity often play a role in who is seen as deserving of justice.
For example, societal expectations of how women are ‘meant to’ behave corresponds to how justice is ‘meant to’ operate. Just as easily as women can be seen as the ‘perfect victim’ in cases where they were perceived as rule-abiding and vulnerable, they can be seen as undeserving of justice when perceived as ‘asking for it’ through their clothing choices or alcohol consumption. Further, the legal system can – and sometimes does – exacerbate the issues it is meant to address. Revictimisation is a common criticism of the way criminal courts handle sexual violence cases.
These examples suggest that the root of the issue lays deeper than just the justice system trying to tidy it up: with more education and less gendered expectations of how men and women should act, society would be more just. Concepts like gender justice can help explain this. It recognises that justice extends beyond the courtroom, because… it does.
What is gender justice?
Although ‘justice’ may be termed as grammatically feminine in many languages, gender justice seeks to address systemic discrimination and oppression for all genders. This does not only apply within the justice system; it aims to work in society as a whole, because justice is for everyone, everywhere.
Embracing gender justice means embracing a society built on equity, not just equality. It also means realising that justice is not merely a matter of handcuffs, fines and prison sentences, but a systemic issue perpetuated by some of the very institutions that promise us protection.
Maybe, then, the question should not be: What gender is justice? Maybe it should be: How can we actively promote gender justice in our everyday lives?